Canadian Art


Deborah Samuel: On Saving the World

Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto Mar 31 to Jul 2 2012
Deborah Samuel <em>Cardinal+Solitaire.I</em> 2012 © Deborah Samuel Courtesy Royal Ontario Museum Deborah Samuel Cardinal+Solitaire.I 2012 © Deborah Samuel Courtesy Royal Ontario Museum

Deborah Samuel <em>Cardinal+Solitaire.I</em> 2012 © Deborah Samuel Courtesy Royal Ontario Museum

There have been times when I wished I’d done something more with my life than make art. Like become a doctor, or a biologist, or anything that might tangibly help other beings. Which is why I felt genuinely happy the other day when I turned on Fashion TV and saw Vivienne Westwood showing off a workshop employing impoverished Africans in Kenya to make her new line of bags. “Fashion can save the world,” she told the camera.

It’s a similar motivation that inspired Deborah Samuel’s series Elegy, now on view at the Royal Ontario Museum. After learning of the BP oil spill in 2010 and being told she couldn’t document birds affected by it, Samuels went ahead and documented the tragedy in her own way. And the way she’s done it is haunting.

In Elegy, Samuel at times animates bird bones as a child might. The mixture of playfulness and gentleness this evokes reminds me very much of those chapels in Italy and Portugal where the walls are lined with the bones of monks. The spinal columns are often strategically placed along the ceiling supports and other bones are placed decoratively. The chapels were built with the intention to invite us to contemplate our impermanence, something I’m surprised to find myself doing among Samuel’s images.

It’s a strange thing when bones arouse tenderness—in this case, a bird’s foot or head. Much of this has to do with Samuel’s presentation. The bones are displayed like portraits and carefully composed against a formal black background. It’s a style more familiar when the subjects are human—and alive.

I begin my daily meditation with an aspiration that ends like this: “May all leave attachment to dear ones and aversion to others, and live believing in the equality of all that lives.” It’s always seemed the most difficult of things to realize, so much so that it’s often just noise to me. But in the room filled with Samuel’s pictures, I understand what it means—not just conceptually, but emotionally.

This isn’t the first time Samuels has shot like this. In her books Dog and Pup, she gives us shots of dogs and dog parts that read more like portraits of people than ones of animals. The images in Andres Serrano’s Body and Soul—details of human cadavers and the infamous Piss Christ (a shot of a crucifix in the artist’s urine)—read much the same way. The lighting picks out details and creates an environment filled with gravitas.

Samuel’s Elegy is provocative because it raises an ethical conundrum. It’s a similar conundrum to the one raised by the Toronto Vegetarian Association–supported ad campaign “Why Love One But Eat The Other?” Why do we dignify human tragedies with such fanfare, and ignore the tragedies of animals? Why honour one and not the other? A hundred years ago we had the clergy answering those questions. Since then, other voices have grown louder—and some of them belong to artists.

This article was first published online on May 24, 2012.


  • Leah Sandals’ Top 3: The Institution, Reframed

    Part 2 of our year-end best-of series offers top picks by our contributing editors and art director, and kicks off with a posting by associate online editor Leah Sandals. For Sandals, art's institutions (and their troubles) are what stood out during 2011.

  • David Hockney: Floral Arrangements

    In this interview, British artist David Hockney speaks with Canadian Art editor Richard Rhodes about his current Toronto show. As Rhodes notes, Hockney’s drawings on iPhones and iPads provide both classical and high-tech rewards.

  • Edward Burtynsky: Ecological Footprints

    As a museum headliner, national prizewinner and focus of a major conference, Edward Burtynsky is all over Toronto’s art ecosystem this season. Here, we round up the details, from his acclaimed Oil to the debut of his big new project on water.



[an error occurred while processing this directive]


  • Janet Cardiff and George Bures Miller: Black Birds

    New York critic Joseph R. Wolin heads to the Park Avenue Armory where Janet Cardiff and George Bures Miller are creating a buzz (and other sounds) at the US premiere of a dark, nightmarish installation originally created for the 2008 Biennale of Sydney.

  • Grange Prize 2012: Hot Shots

    One of Canada’s largest cash-value art prizes—$65,000 in total with $50,000 going to the winner, $5,000 to three runners-up—announced its finalists this week. Take in their wide-ranging works in this slideshow.

  • Wanda Koop: Into the Woods

    A visit to Wanda Koop’s cabin near Riding Mountain National Park in southern Manitoba proves intriguing for Vancouver critic Robin Laurence. There, Laurence writes, Koop bridges old Grey Owl myths with a new series of paintings on our increasingly digital culture.

  • Brad Tinmouth: Survival Strategies

    The basement of an art gallery may seem an unlikely place to create an emergency shelter. However, Xpace's lower gallery is an ideal setting for Brad Tinmouth's “If Times Get Tough or Even If They Don't,” which evokes a cold-war bunker.

  • Wim Delvoye: Blame it on Paris

    Silk-covered pigs, lattice-cut car tires and a tattooed man are just a few of the works that Belgian artist Wim Delvoye has shuttled into the old, Gothic wing of the Louvre this summer. Jill Glessing reviews, finding a terrific amalgam of high and low.

More Online

Report a problem